Healthcare Napkins
Homeopathy doesn't work? No Duh.
Just a few posts ago I talked about how I think that some alternative medicine may need to be investigated to see if it truly does have an effect. And if so, how does it work? We may be able to learn something from these different types of 'healing.'
Myths and falsehoods about health care reform
Interesting blog post at MediaMatters.org
MYTH 1: There is no health care crisis
CLAIM: The health care system currently works fine, and only a purportedly small number of uninsured people would benefit from reform.
RUSH LIMBAUGH: "There really isn't a crisis in health care in this country. The crisis in health care that -- if you wanna say, that does exist -- is the fear that a major illness or catastrophe could wipe you out, which isn't gonna change. In fact, the odds of you being wiped out by a catastrophe or accident once the government gets started running this stuff is greater than if the private sector -- but day-to-day, there's no health care crisis in this country. You can get it. So, it isn't about health care, per se. This is just about gaining control, taking money, and controlling people's lives, and wiping out Republicans -- a nice cherry on top." [Premiere Radio Networks' The Rush Limbaugh Show, 6/18/09]
STEVE DOOCY: "Currently, 90 percent of all Americans have got some sort of health care coverage, which means they are effectively blowing up the system for 5 percent. Now, the 5 percent, you gotta worry about them -- you gotta worry about everybody who doesn't have it. But is it worth all of this for 5 percent?" [Fox News' Fox & Friends, 7/30/09]
REALITY: Roughly 25 million Americans were underinsured in 2007. According to Cathy Schoen, senior vice president of The Commonwealth Fund, "From 2003 to 2007, the number of adults who were insured all year but were underinsured increased by 60 percent. Based on those who incur high out-of-pocket costs relative to their income not counting premiums despite having coverage all year, an estimated 25 million adults under age 65 were underinsured in 2007." [Testimony from Schoen before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, 2/24/09]
The underinsured do not receive adequate care and face financial hardship. Schoen explained that the "experiences" of the underinsured were "similar" to those of the uninsured, noting that "over half of the underinsured and two thirds of the uninsured went without recommended treatment, follow-up care, medications or did not see a doctor when sick. Half of both groups faced financial stress, including medical debt." [Schoen testimony, 2/24/09]
Insurance companies currently rescind policies when their insured customers need treatment. Insurance companies restrict or deny coverage by rescinding health insurance policies on the grounds that customers had undisclosed pre-existing conditions. On June 16, a House Energy and Commerce subcommittee held a hearing exploring this practice, with the goal of examining "the practice of 'post-claims underwriting,' which occurs when insurance companies cancel individual health insurance policies after providers submit claims for medical services rendered." The committee also released a memorandum finding that three major American insurance companies rescinded 19,776 policies for over $300 million in savings over five years and that even that number "significantly undercounts the total number of rescissions" by the companies.
Currently, insurance companies deny coverage based on pre-existing conditions. CNN senior medical correspondent Elizabeth Cohen wrote in a May 14 CNN.com article, "According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, 21 percent of people who apply for health insurance on their own get turned down, charged a higher price or offered a plan that excludes coverage for their pre-existing condition. ... The health insurance industry doesn't deny that people are rejected or charged higher premiums because of pre-existing conditions."
Do I possess the surgeon personality?

Yesterday, our class learned and practiced how to correctly 'scrub' for surgery. During this little lab activity, we were all gowned up and washing our hands when a couple of classmates asked if I was going to be a surgeon.
France: 'Best' Health Care?
ObamaCare Yay Or Nay? The Truth About Canada!
I'd like to see how a follow up video on the US healthcare system would look.
Comparisons
Dr. Silverman reminds us, that statistics aren't always what they seem. Remember to question what you read in the news, because a lot of times you don't have the whole story. Even politicians who are trying to convince us, don't have the whole story.
Is America's healthcare system really that horrible? Maybe not.
Is it fair to compare American health care with systems in Europe or Canada?
AUGUST 18, 2009
by Ralph Silverman, MD, FACS, FASCRS
I am tired of the comparisons people make between health care in the United States and other countries. For instance, there are those who think that we should have universal health care because some European countries and Canada do.
It is true that those countries do have universal health care, but is it a fair comparison?
Who does Canada rely on to defend its borders? When the Germans invaded France in World War II who stormed the beaches at Normandy? The point is, these countries rely on the United States for security when peace is compromised. America allocates trillions of dollars to defend both itself and the rest of the world. No other country does this. That money could easily be used for universal health care.
Furthermore, President Obama has consistently said that health care costs are rising and we aren’t any healthier. The White House uses statistics that demonstrate that, in the U.S., childhood disease is more rampant than in European countries, and that people die earlier Stateside. They ask the question, “Why are we not healthier than other countries when we spend more on health care?”
The answer may lie with American patients, who are more obese than patients in other countries. We eat a diet high in fat and carbohydrate content. As a population, we smoke like there’s no tomorrow. We drive everywhere we go and don’t get any exercise. Instead of exercising to control our blood pressure or diabetes, we sit on the couch and take a pill. We eat ice cream and cake, and then take some insulin to bring down our sugar levels.
Consider Asia. People there eat mainly rice and fish and walk everywhere they go. Smoking is a problem there, but it is worse in the United States. How many 300 pound Asian men and women do you see walking into Burger King in Tokyo? The same is true in France. And guess what? People in these countries are healthier than we are. It’s not surprising.
If anything, the United States should give itself a pat on the back. We have managed to treat our bodies like trash, and yet, the length of life is comparable to other countries that live a much healthier lifestyle. Just imagine if we kept health care at the same level and we, as a population, decided to really change our way of life for the healthier.
The White House and the rest of the government need to make fairer comparisons when contrasting our health care system with those of other countries.
After doing so, perhaps things may not be as bad as they appear.
Ralph Silverman is a colorectal surgeon who blogs at The Colon Doctor.
Bowtie Comeback
My Sincerest Condolences
To the family of the two who died near Tea, SD today. My sincerest condolences go out to you.
Requiescat In Pace
The Alternative Medicine Divide
As I continue on with Dr. Ramachandran's book, Phantoms in the Brain, really gain a new appreciation for the brain and the mind body connection. I already had a huge interest in the world of the brain, and this book is just feeding into a growing obsession. Dr. Ramachandran if you ever stumble onto this blog, please get a hold of me, I would love to do some research with you!
NRMP Charting Data 2009
Kevin MD - There are other reasons too.
Kevin MD comes out with a post today called Medical students want to become primary care doctors, until reality hits.
That reality involves staggering medical school debt, where numbers show that 40 percent of students graduate with debt in excess of $140,000.
And it’s not all about the money. Combined with the fact that theburnout rate is higher in primary care, along with the onerous paperwork and bureaucracy requirements, it’s no wonder why students are avoiding primary care.
A paltry increase in pay isn’t going to stem the medical student tide towards specialty practice.
And to those who suggest that mid-level providers can help with the shortage of primary care doctors, think again. They are not immune to the same economic incentives, and indeed, we’re seeing physician assistants and nurse practitioners gravitate specialists’ offices as well.
But this isn't all Kevin MD. As a current medical student following primary care physicians I can say with certainty that many other unmeasurable reasons make the top of my list on why I might dodge primary care too.
The truth is that raw primary care is sexy. The know-it-all doctor who can do anything steps in and solves almost any problem thrown at him/her. They are the diagnostic master and have a few procedural tricks up their sleeves as well. They are seeing patients of all ages, all races, all extremes, all levels of sickness. But we come to realize very fast that if you don't plan on practicing on the edge of Alaska, or being with Doctors Without Borders for the rest of your life, the primary care career will quickly turn into adjusting med lists, trying to explain why the patient DOESN'T need antibiotics (even though you know they are just going to go to the next doc and try to get the script), and trying to explain to every patient that they really need to diet, exercise, and quit smoking.
Also, the primary care doctor has lost a lot of respect in the clinical arena. The hospitals and clinics regularly tell the primary care doctors how they will practice, what software they will use, and taking the autonomy out of their practices. Yet, specialist and surgeons seem to have individuals dedicated to making sure that the physician is happy with this arrangement or that new machine.
Lastly, primary care just seems the most restricted and thankless. We went into medicine to help those in need, and it just doesn't seem like that's what they do. I can't really put it into words. Maybe I can explain it with an example.
My brother asked me the other day now that I'm so obsessed with flying, if I won the lottery ($200 million) would I stop going to medical school?
That question really caught me off guard. So I thought about it for a few minutes, and lots of different scenarios went through my mind at light speed. Then I settled I want I thought I would seriously do if I had won $200 million.
I would finish medical school, concentrating on either family practice or general surgery (either with a rural emphasis). I would also work on my pilot's license and increase my ratings to fly a little bigger planes. Then I would go around similar to Doctors Without Borders, to third world countries and practice medicine. I would be a real doctor, out there saving the world one person at a time. I would hop from country to country and give medical care. It would be amazing. Helping people who are really poor and in real need, without the worry of crazy amounts of paper work, law suits, or the business side of medicine. Just the patient and the doctor. That's what real primary care is about.
Censoring Yourself
Social media like FB and Twitter are awesome and can be great promotion tools and a way to keep in contact with friends.
Cost of the Private Pilots License
Book Kit (King's School Kit) = $344.75
Third Class Medical Physical = $148.00
Was it worth it? Totally.
Fight back against health insurance lies
[Video Above]
Interesting Medical Fact of the Day
I can already tell that Pathology is going to be an extremely interesting class. Studying disease is one of the main reasons I went to medical school. The human body and disease speaks to me. So without further adieu, the medical fact of the day.
Studies in model organisms, from yeast to mammals, have shown that the most effective way of prolonging life span is calorie restriction. How this works is still not established, but the effect of calorie restriction on longevity appears to be mediated by a family of proteins call sirtuins.
Nurse Practitioners' Role in Expanding Healthcare
How about we break down this article in the TIME.
As the House and Senate prepare to embark on their summer recess without having passed any health-care-reform bills, President Obama's dreams of radically restructuring the system have, at least for now, bumped up against the reality of Washington politics. But even if Congress manages to overcome the many obstacles and pass some kind of meaningful reform this fall, the goal of covering some 50 million currently uninsured Americans will encounter a whole new range of hurdles. Chief among them is that there almost certainly won't be enough doctors to care for that many new patients.
Even without reform, experts on the health-care labor force estimate there is currently a 30% shortage in the ranks of primary-care physicians. Fewer than 10% of the 2008 graduating class of medical students opted for a career in primary care, with the rest choosing more lucrative specialties. That could pose problems if a national health-care bill is enacted. After Massachusetts enacted mandates for universal health insurance in 2006, those with new coverage quickly overwhelmed the state's supply of primary-care doctors, driving up the time patients must wait to get routine appointments. It stands to reason that primary-care doctors could be similarly overwhelmed on a national scale.
But there is an existing group of providers that health reformers are hoping can help fill this gap: nurse practitioners. Depending on the state in which they practice, nurse practitioners, with advanced training often including master's degrees in nursing, can often treat patients and diagnose ailments as well as prescribe medication. And they can do these things at a lower cost than doctors — Medicare, for example, reimburses nurse practitioners 80% of what is paid to doctors for the same services.
The nurse-practitioner profession was created in 1965, the same year as the invention of Medicare, which dramatically increased the need for primary-care providers. Yet while nurse practitioners can be valuable assets in the context of health reform, they have also created a conflict with doctors, many of whom are not keen on being supplanted by providers with far less training; doctors in some cases have lobbied to restrict the services of nurse practitioners. "In some situations, it can be a turf battle," acknowledges Rebecca Patton, president of the American Nursing Association.
In addition to providing many of the same services less expensively, nurse practitioners offer something else that makes them darlings to health reformers: a focus on patient-centered care and preventive medicine. "We seem to be health care's best-kept secret," says Jan Powers, health-policy director for the Academy of Nurse Practitioners. Nurse practitioners may have less medical education than full-fledged doctors, but they have far more training in less measurable skills like bedside manner and counseling. "In the United States, we are so physician-centric in our health system," says Patton. "But it should be about wellness and prevention, not about procedures and disease management."
President Obama told the American Medical Association in May that the government should do "more to reward medical students who choose a career as a primary-care physician and who choose to work in underserved areas instead of a more lucrative path." As part of health reform, the Administration wants more money for the National Health Service Corps, which offers loan forgiveness to primary-care providers — including nurse practitioners as well as doctors — who agree to work in rural and remote areas. But even if these measures encourage more medical students to pursue careers in general practice, it will take years to have a real impact. Nurse practitioners, on the other hand, require fewer years of training and can therefore bump up their ranks faster.
In the recently released House health-reform bill, nurse practitioners (and physicians' assistants, another relatively new, but smaller, category of medical professionals who can perform medical procedures and often prescribe medication) are listed alongside doctors as primary-care providers. Nurse practitioners lobbied hard for this legislative language in meetings with White House health officials, including Nancy-Ann DeParle, Obama's health-reform czar. The nurse-practitioners lobby is hoping such federal recognition of the central role the profession can play in a revamped health system will exert pressure on states to ease restrictions. A patchwork of state laws now dictates how much freedom nurse practitioners have, ranging from states like Alabama, where nurse practitioners can work only under the supervision of a physician, to Oregon, where nurse practitioners are permitted to run their own private practices.
Class of 2013
Starting Tomorrow

Well it's official, the last day of summer is upon us. Classes begin tomorrow, and I will start my 2nd year of medical school. Looking back at my last scheduled summer of my educational career, I have to say I am happy with it. I feel rested yet not like I didn't get anything done. I feel productive, yet I don't feel burned out. With a private pilot's license, Avera Clinical First Steps, Scholarship Pathways, two physician shadowing experiences, and a good amount of time spent with friends an family all behind me, I have to say bring on the 2nd year!
Archives
-
▼
2009
(240)
-
►
December
(18)
- Christmas Break
- Am I an idiot here or what?
- Subluxations and Fixations
- Snarky Comments - Apology
- Herbs and Chiropractic Safety
- Quick Concerns from the Lunch & Learn
- Level UP!
- Specialty Recruitment?
- Snow
- Awkward
- Quote of the Week!
- The Bachelors Degree is the New High School Degree...
- Deep Brain Stimulation & The Age of the Brain
- Study Journal
- Scrubs
- What is driving medical students away from primary...
- Some Objective Data
- Goljan Is ALWAYS Right
-
►
November
(26)
- Female doctors hurt productivity
- Depressed Student
- Exam = Procrastination
- Anti Vaccine Cheerleader
- Brag
- The Two Tier System
- Long Distance Relationships
- Milk - In Balls
- Applied Science
- Diversity Programs
- Awesome Pharmacology Quote
- More Vaccinations
- Alarm Clock
- A Different Kind of Busy
- Dr. D
- Neurosonics Audiomedical Labs Inc.
- More on the Dystonia Cheerleader
- Dystonia Cheerleader
- Flying
- Test Bombing
- Funny Motivational Posters
- The Virus Video
- Some Dude
- The Dermatologist - Saving Lives
- Pineapple Crazy
- Peep Surgery
-
▼
August
(22)
- Healthcare Napkins
- Pay For Performance
- Homeopathy doesn't work? No Duh.
- Myths and falsehoods about health care reform
- Synchronized Bicycling - WOW
- Sweet Poster
- Do I possess the surgeon personality?
- France: 'Best' Health Care?
- ObamaCare Yay Or Nay? The Truth About Canada!
- Comparisons
- Bowtie Comeback
- My Sincerest Condolences
- The Alternative Medicine Divide
- NRMP Charting Data 2009
- Kevin MD - There are other reasons too.
- Censoring Yourself
- Cost of the Private Pilots License
- Fight back against health insurance lies
- Interesting Medical Fact of the Day
- Nurse Practitioners' Role in Expanding Healthcare
- Class of 2013
- Starting Tomorrow
-
►
December
(18)
Labels
- abortion (4)
- AIDS/HIV (4)
- alcoholism (1)
- alternative medicine (13)
- basic science (12)
- EMT (7)
- First Aid (1)
- fun (51)
- health topics (14)
- healthcare costs (42)
- high school (1)
- homosexual (1)
- hunnbun (2)
- interesting (101)
- malpractice (9)
- medical ethics (34)
- medical school (74)
- medical specialty (40)
- medical students (74)
- mid-level providers (13)
- military (1)
- myself (103)
- nursing (8)
- patients (26)
- pilot (11)
- politics (35)
- practice of medicine (94)
- Pre-Med (23)
- rant (25)
- religion (5)
- Sanford School of Medicine (32)
- smoking (1)
- south dakota (21)
- stupid (7)
- vaccines (4)
About Me
- Shawn Vuong
- MS2 at the University of South Dakota Sanford School of Medicine
Blog Roll
-
-
-
Skull Light19 hours ago
-
-
-
-
-
The Dinosaur Speaks1 day ago
-
Reassessing the Dartmouth Data2 days ago
-
I Have A Secret1 week ago
-
Prince of Denmark1 week ago
-
Bad idea3 weeks ago
-
Wut1 month ago
-
Med Glossary, Part 53 months ago
-
Automatic chest compressions5 months ago







